Atlantis Diner Reviews West Islip NY

Louise Sandberg

Employees courteous. I waited a while for takeout because sweet potato fries were made fresh. Order was not correct, but I did not check it before I left and did not go back to correct it. Toast was cold, a little hard and butter not melted. I am grateful It is very close to Good Sam Hospital where my husband is a patient and the food was hot and tasty (except the toast) and lasted 2 days.

MICHAEL BALBOA

Wonderful Service, our waitress was super attentive and had a great Vibe. Great eggs / breakfast and also really good coffee.. This diner has a great positive vibe.

Jenifer Mintz

We have been coming here on and off for years. Every time we come from Florida we stop in. The deluxe burger platter is always our go to and the burgers were just frozen patties and completely over cooked, gross. The cookies in the case were overpriced and stale. We were so terribly disappointed by our entire experience. The food is less than sub par.

Myah L

I had the Romano Burger which was delicious. Good service. Will revisit.

Josh

Great diner. Best and biggest panini ever had. Even the potatoe salad and Cole slaw was good.