Benvenuto's Italian Grill Reviews Beaver Dam WI
Reviews of Benvenuto's Italian Grill Beaver Dam WI
durielthered
Food was fantastic. The goat cheese and fig jam dip appetizer was excellent. My ribeye was cooked perfectly. The garlic mashed potatoes and french onion soup were delicious. The cheese ravioli is an excellent choice. Will definitely return next time I get the chance. Wait staff was also great.
Jessica Wood
We ordered delivery. The salads tasted like they weren't rinsed. Almost a dusty flavor to them. Brussel sprouts way over cooked & too salty & the sirloin asked for it to be medium but it was well done. Also ordered 2 spaghetti & 3 Alfredo. Thought it would come out to between $80-$100 but $146! Ridiculous. Especially when it didn't taste that good and wasn't cooked the way it should have been.
Rachel Holland
I used to love this place. But over the past few years it has really decreased in quality yet raises in prices. Every time I try to give them another chance the food is either salty as all heck I can’t eat it, or it’s burnt. We last visited in February with our free meal deal for our anniversary (email specials). And our $$$$ steaks were nothing to write home about. I am not sure if it’s the chefs or the quality of ingredients but it’s a shame to see the decline at such a long standing restaurant.
Roxanne Schroedl
Ordered well done steak it was rare husband steak was not medium well and couldn’t cut with a steak knife. Spent $67 on food I had to take home to cook myself. Any cook should be able to cook a steak. Never returning there again.
Alexis Keblin
THE WORST EXPERIENCE
As a family, we have been here many times and always enjoyed the food and service. Unfortunately, due to last night’s service, we will never be returning. The waitress never introduced herself or even smiled. When we asked for bread, she said it had to wait until we order. After waiting 40 minutes for our food (family of 6) we ordered our second drinks at 8:42. We were then asked “How much have you been drinking and who is driving home?” WHAT?! We were flabbergasted as a set of 30 and 60 year olds. We were told it was last call at 8:30, they did not ask us beforehand if we wanted a last drink! Then a manager came by and asked us again the same questions.. FOR A SECOND DRINK.
After being so offended and dealing with TERRIBLE service, we canceled our drink orders and asked for our food to go.
We expressed our concerns with the staff that we had never had these issues here before or literally anywhere else! We were still charged for the drinks we did not even get as well as had a separate waitress harass us on our way to our cars yelling, “That was uncalled for!” What, wanting food and drinks at a restaurant?
I do not know what happened to this place, but it was seriously the worst experience ever.
If you do not want a table of six 1.5 hours before closing, you shouldn’t have taken our table. Also, you should have stopped at our table BEFORE last call to let us.
We were celebrating two birthdays and another birthday of an aunt we just lost in February and this staff turned it into the worst experience we have ever had.
Also, they served the most bland French onion soup that actually made me vomit. If you like plain, warm water with onions and greasy cheese - this is perfect for you!
Y’all need to fix yourselves. If I could give negative stars, I would.
durielthered
Food was fantastic. The goat cheese and fig jam dip appetizer was excellent. My ribeye was cooked perfectly. The garlic mashed potatoes and french onion soup were delicious. The cheese ravioli is an excellent choice. Will definitely return next time I get the chance. Wait staff was also great.
Jessica Wood
We ordered delivery. The salads tasted like they weren't rinsed. Almost a dusty flavor to them. Brussel sprouts way over cooked & too salty & the sirloin asked for it to be medium but it was well done. Also ordered 2 spaghetti & 3 Alfredo. Thought it would come out to between $80-$100 but $146! Ridiculous. Especially when it didn't taste that good and wasn't cooked the way it should have been.
Rachel Holland
I used to love this place. But over the past few years it has really decreased in quality yet raises in prices. Every time I try to give them another chance the food is either salty as all heck I can’t eat it, or it’s burnt. We last visited in February with our free meal deal for our anniversary (email specials). And our $$$$ steaks were nothing to write home about. I am not sure if it’s the chefs or the quality of ingredients but it’s a shame to see the decline at such a long standing restaurant.
Roxanne Schroedl
Ordered well done steak it was rare husband steak was not medium well and couldn’t cut with a steak knife. Spent $67 on food I had to take home to cook myself. Any cook should be able to cook a steak. Never returning there again.
Alexis Keblin
THE WORST EXPERIENCE As a family, we have been here many times and always enjoyed the food and service. Unfortunately, due to last night’s service, we will never be returning. The waitress never introduced herself or even smiled. When we asked for bread, she said it had to wait until we order. After waiting 40 minutes for our food (family of 6) we ordered our second drinks at 8:42. We were then asked “How much have you been drinking and who is driving home?” WHAT?! We were flabbergasted as a set of 30 and 60 year olds. We were told it was last call at 8:30, they did not ask us beforehand if we wanted a last drink! Then a manager came by and asked us again the same questions.. FOR A SECOND DRINK. After being so offended and dealing with TERRIBLE service, we canceled our drink orders and asked for our food to go. We expressed our concerns with the staff that we had never had these issues here before or literally anywhere else! We were still charged for the drinks we did not even get as well as had a separate waitress harass us on our way to our cars yelling, “That was uncalled for!” What, wanting food and drinks at a restaurant? I do not know what happened to this place, but it was seriously the worst experience ever. If you do not want a table of six 1.5 hours before closing, you shouldn’t have taken our table. Also, you should have stopped at our table BEFORE last call to let us. We were celebrating two birthdays and another birthday of an aunt we just lost in February and this staff turned it into the worst experience we have ever had. Also, they served the most bland French onion soup that actually made me vomit. If you like plain, warm water with onions and greasy cheese - this is perfect for you! Y’all need to fix yourselves. If I could give negative stars, I would.