Malcolm's Reviews Schenectady NY
Reviews of Malcolm's Schenectady NY
Pat B
First time here! Absolutely amazing meal. We ordered the price fix meals and the portions were perfect! The variety of flavors were incredible. The Brussels sprouts were cooked to perfection and exploding with favor. The Espresso Martini had a hint of different flavors that made it delicious! The duck and sweet potatoes were beyond tasty! The staff was friendly and helpful. Highly recommend checking it out! Can’t wait to go back 💃🏻
Paul Warren
The good: The waiter was friendly and professional, genuinely seemed to care about the dining experience. This is the reason for two stars instead of one.
The bad: It took over one hour to receive the salads let alone the entrees. One of our drink orders was missed completely. The restaurant claimed to be understaffed, so maybe on other days the experience is better. If the restaurant was having issues serious enough to impact operations so bad we would have appreciated being warned ahead of time... we would have come back another day.
The ugly: The cuts of steak were very poor in quality, one cut may have been the worst I have ever seen served. The other items did not live up to other farm to table restaurants we have visited.
Being short staffed shouldn't impact the quality of the ingredients. The prices were extremely high for what we received in general.
We wanted to like this restaurant, we wanted to have a relaxing, stress free dinner. That did not happen.
Ingvor van Zuuk
Poor quality of food! High prices for what you get! Nice service. Chefs need more training in professional fine dining restaurant overrated. Good location
Tom P
The snap pea salad put me in a flow state that lasted through the cheese plate. Really a sublime dining experience. Don’t miss the Sticky Toffee Pudding. Germain is Pirsig’s welder.
Janina Altagracia
The waitress was awesome however it took over 2 hours to receive our food. Also, by the time we were able to order the meal of choice ran out 🤦🏽♀️.
Great folks but needs improvement
Pat B
First time here! Absolutely amazing meal. We ordered the price fix meals and the portions were perfect! The variety of flavors were incredible. The Brussels sprouts were cooked to perfection and exploding with favor. The Espresso Martini had a hint of different flavors that made it delicious! The duck and sweet potatoes were beyond tasty! The staff was friendly and helpful. Highly recommend checking it out! Can’t wait to go back 💃🏻
Paul Warren
The good: The waiter was friendly and professional, genuinely seemed to care about the dining experience. This is the reason for two stars instead of one. The bad: It took over one hour to receive the salads let alone the entrees. One of our drink orders was missed completely. The restaurant claimed to be understaffed, so maybe on other days the experience is better. If the restaurant was having issues serious enough to impact operations so bad we would have appreciated being warned ahead of time... we would have come back another day. The ugly: The cuts of steak were very poor in quality, one cut may have been the worst I have ever seen served. The other items did not live up to other farm to table restaurants we have visited. Being short staffed shouldn't impact the quality of the ingredients. The prices were extremely high for what we received in general. We wanted to like this restaurant, we wanted to have a relaxing, stress free dinner. That did not happen.
Ingvor van Zuuk
Poor quality of food! High prices for what you get! Nice service. Chefs need more training in professional fine dining restaurant overrated. Good location
Tom P
The snap pea salad put me in a flow state that lasted through the cheese plate. Really a sublime dining experience. Don’t miss the Sticky Toffee Pudding. Germain is Pirsig’s welder.
Janina Altagracia
The waitress was awesome however it took over 2 hours to receive our food. Also, by the time we were able to order the meal of choice ran out 🤦🏽♀️. Great folks but needs improvement