Old Germantown Reviews Germantown WI
Reviews of Old Germantown Germantown WI
Matt Adams
This was our first time here. We had their pizza and some apps. Food was served very hot and was delicious. They brew their own beer and also have guest taps. The manager said it is best to get there early because there can be a wait the later you arrive. Staff was very friendly and helpful. They showed us how to order through our phone. We will be back!
Riva Treasure
Great service, great beer, and great ambiance! They have it all! All of the food (multiple visits) has been super tasty and the owner is very kind and helpful. Especially when my baby knocked over a full beer. He kindly cleaned up and replaced the beer at no cost. We love supporting local!
Jen Peters
Really great place. Wood fired pizza, homemade sausage, house brewed & other local beers, great desserts, lovely patio. Live music most weekends. Make a reservation or get there early though, they fill up at 5pm! A little hard to find as it's a farm set way back from the road with little signage - turn at the red wagon.
Jacob K
Awesome spot with great food. Scott the owner took time to visit our table and truly cares about everything. Pizzas were amazing, great beer selection as well. Thanks for a great evening!
Stacey Soden
UPDATE: we came back the next day (Sunday) and had a much better experience! We brought a booster seat from home and decided to eat inside just to make things a bit easier. The line to order was short, our drinks came quickly and the food was super tasty! I'm glad we gave this place another shot - it didn't disappoint.
What an unfortunate mess! This was our first time attempting to eat here, and we arrived around 4:30pm on a Saturday with our almost-2 year old. There isn't a hostess, just a sign that says "take a menu, grab a seat, and order at the bar". ....but we couldn't find any menus? Since the line was super long we figured we'd try and find a table outside. After getting that sorted, we discovered they didn't have any standard high chairs, which was a bummer. After deciding what we wanted to eat, we ran into another problem: since they don't have any servers, how were we supposed to save/reserve our table when one of us had to go inside and stand in line to order, and the other one was busy watching the toddler in their little sand pit/play area? The last straw was when we finally went in to place our order only to be told it would be an hour wait for pizza. An hour wait at 5pm?! At that point we decided to throw in the towel and head elsewhere.
The menus looked delicious, the staff we interacted with were friendly, and the atmosphere was great, so we do plan on coming back. We'll just have to make sure it's on a weeknight and without our kiddo.
Matt Adams
This was our first time here. We had their pizza and some apps. Food was served very hot and was delicious. They brew their own beer and also have guest taps. The manager said it is best to get there early because there can be a wait the later you arrive. Staff was very friendly and helpful. They showed us how to order through our phone. We will be back!
Riva Treasure
Great service, great beer, and great ambiance! They have it all! All of the food (multiple visits) has been super tasty and the owner is very kind and helpful. Especially when my baby knocked over a full beer. He kindly cleaned up and replaced the beer at no cost. We love supporting local!
Jen Peters
Really great place. Wood fired pizza, homemade sausage, house brewed & other local beers, great desserts, lovely patio. Live music most weekends. Make a reservation or get there early though, they fill up at 5pm! A little hard to find as it's a farm set way back from the road with little signage - turn at the red wagon.
Jacob K
Awesome spot with great food. Scott the owner took time to visit our table and truly cares about everything. Pizzas were amazing, great beer selection as well. Thanks for a great evening!
Stacey Soden
UPDATE: we came back the next day (Sunday) and had a much better experience! We brought a booster seat from home and decided to eat inside just to make things a bit easier. The line to order was short, our drinks came quickly and the food was super tasty! I'm glad we gave this place another shot - it didn't disappoint. What an unfortunate mess! This was our first time attempting to eat here, and we arrived around 4:30pm on a Saturday with our almost-2 year old. There isn't a hostess, just a sign that says "take a menu, grab a seat, and order at the bar". ....but we couldn't find any menus? Since the line was super long we figured we'd try and find a table outside. After getting that sorted, we discovered they didn't have any standard high chairs, which was a bummer. After deciding what we wanted to eat, we ran into another problem: since they don't have any servers, how were we supposed to save/reserve our table when one of us had to go inside and stand in line to order, and the other one was busy watching the toddler in their little sand pit/play area? The last straw was when we finally went in to place our order only to be told it would be an hour wait for pizza. An hour wait at 5pm?! At that point we decided to throw in the towel and head elsewhere. The menus looked delicious, the staff we interacted with were friendly, and the atmosphere was great, so we do plan on coming back. We'll just have to make sure it's on a weeknight and without our kiddo.