Post - American Eatery Reviews Hudson WI
Reviews of Post - American Eatery Hudson WI
Hailey Biagini
Hosted our rehearsal dinner here for our wedding and it was awesome!!! We got endless raving reviews about the food from friends/family and Shawn and team were incredibly accommodating! We had a wide variety of options for food to customize it to what worked best for our budget and taste. We did spaghetti, lasagna and pizzas - all were delicious! Huge thank you to the Post team for making our wedding weekend so memorable!
Tom Bleicher
Great place to enjoy lunch or dinner! Situated in an old post office in Hudson, WI just off the river. Food was fantastic! Decent selection of craft beer and a full bar should you prefer that instead. Service was a little slow, but we’re not going to fault them for that, especially in the current climate of things. All in all, would definitely recommend a visit if you’re in the area! Also, they have complimentary parking behind their restaurant! Cheers!
paul stevenson
After sooo many terrific meals here, it feels unimaginable rating my last experience three ☆'s. Sorry, but he chicken fingers were dry, hard, and greasy tasting. Why is this a big deal? Because Postmark had earned a reputation for consistently serving the most delicious fingers in the valley. What happened? New recipe? New preparation method? Hoping this is an anomaly. All that said, we were a party of 8 and everyone was happy with their meal except the people who took my recommendation on the chicken. And the service was superlative. Thanks again Amy!
Nick Doten
Postmark is always a good choice in Hudson. It's one of the very few places that will take a reservation on a Friday or Saturday night. It won't knock your socks off, but it's consistently very good. Service has always been friendly and good has been tasty.
Dave Barger
We were here for the first time since the new ownership took over. Wait staff was very friendly and on top of things. Food was excellent and desserts were very good also ( drinks go without saying ). There was an odd incident where a couple tried to bring their small dog in and were told no pets were allowed. The dog owner got very confrontational right away. The dog did not have on a service vest and listening to the conversation it appeared the card for the dog was not a legit service dog card. The dog owner seemed pretty hostile and threatened the staff with litigation. It’s not really a place I would bring an animal, unless I truly needed it’s assistance. But then it should have proper credentials. Other than that scenario, things were great and I would definitely return. Lobster Ravioli would be an excellent choice, we also had the walleye which was good too.It was a little noisy but it was crowded that night.
Hailey Biagini
Hosted our rehearsal dinner here for our wedding and it was awesome!!! We got endless raving reviews about the food from friends/family and Shawn and team were incredibly accommodating! We had a wide variety of options for food to customize it to what worked best for our budget and taste. We did spaghetti, lasagna and pizzas - all were delicious! Huge thank you to the Post team for making our wedding weekend so memorable!
Tom Bleicher
Great place to enjoy lunch or dinner! Situated in an old post office in Hudson, WI just off the river. Food was fantastic! Decent selection of craft beer and a full bar should you prefer that instead. Service was a little slow, but we’re not going to fault them for that, especially in the current climate of things. All in all, would definitely recommend a visit if you’re in the area! Also, they have complimentary parking behind their restaurant! Cheers!
paul stevenson
After sooo many terrific meals here, it feels unimaginable rating my last experience three ☆'s. Sorry, but he chicken fingers were dry, hard, and greasy tasting. Why is this a big deal? Because Postmark had earned a reputation for consistently serving the most delicious fingers in the valley. What happened? New recipe? New preparation method? Hoping this is an anomaly. All that said, we were a party of 8 and everyone was happy with their meal except the people who took my recommendation on the chicken. And the service was superlative. Thanks again Amy!
Nick Doten
Postmark is always a good choice in Hudson. It's one of the very few places that will take a reservation on a Friday or Saturday night. It won't knock your socks off, but it's consistently very good. Service has always been friendly and good has been tasty.
Dave Barger
We were here for the first time since the new ownership took over. Wait staff was very friendly and on top of things. Food was excellent and desserts were very good also ( drinks go without saying ). There was an odd incident where a couple tried to bring their small dog in and were told no pets were allowed. The dog owner got very confrontational right away. The dog did not have on a service vest and listening to the conversation it appeared the card for the dog was not a legit service dog card. The dog owner seemed pretty hostile and threatened the staff with litigation. It’s not really a place I would bring an animal, unless I truly needed it’s assistance. But then it should have proper credentials. Other than that scenario, things were great and I would definitely return. Lobster Ravioli would be an excellent choice, we also had the walleye which was good too.It was a little noisy but it was crowded that night.