Hubbard Avenue Diner Reviews Middleton WI
Reviews of Hubbard Avenue Diner Middleton WI
Paul Quella (PQ5876)
There was nothing special this time. Good meatloaf meal with veggies and mash potatoes. Gravey is just right. No dessert this time. It was not busy at all for a Tuesday. Still clean place and nice booths. Also, we had soup of the day and grilled cheese. It looks like it could use a decor refresh through.
G W
While ordering. I asked if they could hold my pancakes for a 5 minutes. The server was not sure. She checked. Came back and said they could hold in the window. Which would be that the pancakes would be dried out or another could have the chance to take by mistake. So I said just bring them out. So now I will have cold pancakes because I like to eat my eggs and other items before my pancakes. Server tried for me. I appreciate that.
My hashbrowns were not even warm. Plus my pancakes are already cold. This is wrong. I am thinking that our food was sitting in the window to long. When I said something. Our server requested another order.
I was trying to eat faster so I could actually eat my pancakes. I bit my tongue. So I didn't even finish my food.
I feel they could have waited 5 minutes to make my pancakes. This negative review would not have happened and my tongue would not have happened. Just a disrespectful.
Kiley Weber
Hubbard Avenue Diner is a local restaurant and is part of the food fight restaurant group. Food Fight is a locally owned/operated restaurant group with unique and diverse restaurants in the greater Madison area. The Diner makes all of their desserts in house and are absolutely to die for, some flavors rotate seasonally and some stick around year round. I highly suggest the Duo of Silk pie if you enjoy chocolate and peanut butter. The blueberry cheesecake and the key lime pie are also delicious. The Diner has great tasting food and is the typical diner/breakfast foods.
Carol Cady-Severson
Food was good. Service was terrible. Very unfriendly server. We were mostly done when she asked how our food tasted. Asked for medium burger, it was beyond well done. Did not top off empty water glasses. Did not take empty plates away and we asked for one check, we got three. Never asked about dessert just plopped down checks and walked away. The service has always been top notch. Server definitely not a people person.
Rick Smoke
I have honed my ability to detect a good pie serving establishment for many years now. I am pleased to report that this effort paid off once again when I found this gem of a restaurant. Be happy, go here and eat! 🥧
Paul Quella (PQ5876)
There was nothing special this time. Good meatloaf meal with veggies and mash potatoes. Gravey is just right. No dessert this time. It was not busy at all for a Tuesday. Still clean place and nice booths. Also, we had soup of the day and grilled cheese. It looks like it could use a decor refresh through.
G W
While ordering. I asked if they could hold my pancakes for a 5 minutes. The server was not sure. She checked. Came back and said they could hold in the window. Which would be that the pancakes would be dried out or another could have the chance to take by mistake. So I said just bring them out. So now I will have cold pancakes because I like to eat my eggs and other items before my pancakes. Server tried for me. I appreciate that. My hashbrowns were not even warm. Plus my pancakes are already cold. This is wrong. I am thinking that our food was sitting in the window to long. When I said something. Our server requested another order. I was trying to eat faster so I could actually eat my pancakes. I bit my tongue. So I didn't even finish my food. I feel they could have waited 5 minutes to make my pancakes. This negative review would not have happened and my tongue would not have happened. Just a disrespectful.
Kiley Weber
Hubbard Avenue Diner is a local restaurant and is part of the food fight restaurant group. Food Fight is a locally owned/operated restaurant group with unique and diverse restaurants in the greater Madison area. The Diner makes all of their desserts in house and are absolutely to die for, some flavors rotate seasonally and some stick around year round. I highly suggest the Duo of Silk pie if you enjoy chocolate and peanut butter. The blueberry cheesecake and the key lime pie are also delicious. The Diner has great tasting food and is the typical diner/breakfast foods.
Carol Cady-Severson
Food was good. Service was terrible. Very unfriendly server. We were mostly done when she asked how our food tasted. Asked for medium burger, it was beyond well done. Did not top off empty water glasses. Did not take empty plates away and we asked for one check, we got three. Never asked about dessert just plopped down checks and walked away. The service has always been top notch. Server definitely not a people person.
Rick Smoke
I have honed my ability to detect a good pie serving establishment for many years now. I am pleased to report that this effort paid off once again when I found this gem of a restaurant. Be happy, go here and eat! 🥧