Jim Dandy's Pub & Grill Reviews Oak Creek WI
Reviews of Jim Dandy's Pub & Grill Oak Creek WI
Brett W.
To start, do not use their online reservations. Our group of 6 arrived and checked in. We were told they had no reservation for us. I mentioned the online reservation. I was told it was meaningless as they had no computer or any means to view those from online. Middle of the road review as the food was good and the service was not. We got a table relatively quick as it wasn't overly busy. Very slow to get drinks. Good thing we ordered appetizers because it took an hour and 15min. to get our meals on a Friday eve. Mind you again it was not very busy. They could not even keep up with our drinks which was only one an hour for the 2 hours we spent their. Good thing we were with friends to help pass the time!
Katrina Hennings
I was not impressed. I went here for my birthday last week due to the nice pictures of food I’ve seen. There was only one lady working all tables and bar area. My shrimp was cold, rubbery, no seasoning and definitely wasn’t grilled. There was no grill lines or flavor to it. Definitely not fancy as they make it look.
Stephanie Weber
After reading the online reviews, I really didn't want to try this place, but my husband had his heart set on trying it. So, I tried to approach it with an open mind and give the place a chance.
I'm so glad I did!
The bacon wrapped shrimp was amazing, my husband's steak was gigantic and perfectly cooked, and my fish sandwich was also very good.
The service was prompt, the food arrived quickly and we experienced none of the issues that others seemed to have.
It's not fancy,but it was quality food at decent prices. We'll definitely be back.
Ashley John
I dont usually give a bad review unless the service was very poor. I was so disappointed as their food is very good. We came in for a friends birthday and had called the day prior for a reservation as we had 10+ people. We were told they had no reservation and instead of accommodating us, the waitresses stood around arguing about who was going to take our party. We had to find enough tables and arrange them ourselves. Was 20 minutes before we were even asked what we wanted to drink so by the time we were finally asked we were ready to order our food as well. Also to get the tomahawk special you have to call in advance, which we did. We requested 6 and they only had 4. We arrived at 7pm and were not served our food until 830pm. Very disappointed!
KEVIN VIEL
I went there with family. We ordered ribs and steak. The ribs did NOT have any smokey flavor. They were the worst ribs I ever had. They were oven roasted and slapped with cheap BBQ sauce. The steak my family member had was awful. Over cooked and the seasoning was bad. We will never be back and recommend everyone to go somewhere else. I am posting this on Facebook to warn people.
Brett W.
To start, do not use their online reservations. Our group of 6 arrived and checked in. We were told they had no reservation for us. I mentioned the online reservation. I was told it was meaningless as they had no computer or any means to view those from online. Middle of the road review as the food was good and the service was not. We got a table relatively quick as it wasn't overly busy. Very slow to get drinks. Good thing we ordered appetizers because it took an hour and 15min. to get our meals on a Friday eve. Mind you again it was not very busy. They could not even keep up with our drinks which was only one an hour for the 2 hours we spent their. Good thing we were with friends to help pass the time!
Katrina Hennings
I was not impressed. I went here for my birthday last week due to the nice pictures of food I’ve seen. There was only one lady working all tables and bar area. My shrimp was cold, rubbery, no seasoning and definitely wasn’t grilled. There was no grill lines or flavor to it. Definitely not fancy as they make it look.
Stephanie Weber
After reading the online reviews, I really didn't want to try this place, but my husband had his heart set on trying it. So, I tried to approach it with an open mind and give the place a chance. I'm so glad I did! The bacon wrapped shrimp was amazing, my husband's steak was gigantic and perfectly cooked, and my fish sandwich was also very good. The service was prompt, the food arrived quickly and we experienced none of the issues that others seemed to have. It's not fancy,but it was quality food at decent prices. We'll definitely be back.
Ashley John
I dont usually give a bad review unless the service was very poor. I was so disappointed as their food is very good. We came in for a friends birthday and had called the day prior for a reservation as we had 10+ people. We were told they had no reservation and instead of accommodating us, the waitresses stood around arguing about who was going to take our party. We had to find enough tables and arrange them ourselves. Was 20 minutes before we were even asked what we wanted to drink so by the time we were finally asked we were ready to order our food as well. Also to get the tomahawk special you have to call in advance, which we did. We requested 6 and they only had 4. We arrived at 7pm and were not served our food until 830pm. Very disappointed!
KEVIN VIEL
I went there with family. We ordered ribs and steak. The ribs did NOT have any smokey flavor. They were the worst ribs I ever had. They were oven roasted and slapped with cheap BBQ sauce. The steak my family member had was awful. Over cooked and the seasoning was bad. We will never be back and recommend everyone to go somewhere else. I am posting this on Facebook to warn people.