Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Reviews Sun Prairie WI
Reviews of Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Sun Prairie WI
Gregory Hunter
Great bar area in the Hilton Garden Inn with a large patio as well. They have plenty of options for Italian as well as some fantastic appetizers with good portions. They also offer light portions on many appetizers. Very clean spot. They also have a good happy hour from 4pm - 6pm. Not to forget the staff are all exceptional!!!
Warren Carlton
We had a group of 9 and they were able to seat us immediately. The environment was excellent. Some of us had a drink at the bar before being seated.we placed our appetizers order along w/ drink orders. Our waitress was great. She came back after bringing out the drinks and took our main course orders. Our appetizers came out shortly thereafter. We finished w/ our appetizers when the salads came out. Shortly after, the dinners came out. Food was excellent. Steak was cooked as ordered (medium well), the shrimp were seasoned very well, not over seasoned either. And the pasta marinara was very good too.
Xi Wu
A decent place. Had a great experience. Of course this place needs more time to be more mature (service, food, etc.) But I think it will eventually be there.
Kiera Mancl
I made a reservation here over the phone, very quick and easy! It was the first time my partner and I had ever been there and it was for his birthday! This place gets a 10/10 from me. The service was amazing, I regret not asking my waiters name because he absolutely made the experience so good! The service was good and the food was GREAT! Affordable fine dining in my opinion. To top it off, he got a piece of tiramisu cake for free for his birthday! We have already recommended this place to friends and only left there 2 hours ago😂 We will most definitely be back again! Thank you!
Victoria Bourdon
Our server was great. Steak came under cooked they took it back, then proceeded to burn it and dry it out. Didn't comp or anything for the burnt unedible steak. I'm not sure if it will be worth returning.
Gregory Hunter
Great bar area in the Hilton Garden Inn with a large patio as well. They have plenty of options for Italian as well as some fantastic appetizers with good portions. They also offer light portions on many appetizers. Very clean spot. They also have a good happy hour from 4pm - 6pm. Not to forget the staff are all exceptional!!!
Warren Carlton
We had a group of 9 and they were able to seat us immediately. The environment was excellent. Some of us had a drink at the bar before being seated.we placed our appetizers order along w/ drink orders. Our waitress was great. She came back after bringing out the drinks and took our main course orders. Our appetizers came out shortly thereafter. We finished w/ our appetizers when the salads came out. Shortly after, the dinners came out. Food was excellent. Steak was cooked as ordered (medium well), the shrimp were seasoned very well, not over seasoned either. And the pasta marinara was very good too.
Xi Wu
A decent place. Had a great experience. Of course this place needs more time to be more mature (service, food, etc.) But I think it will eventually be there.
Kiera Mancl
I made a reservation here over the phone, very quick and easy! It was the first time my partner and I had ever been there and it was for his birthday! This place gets a 10/10 from me. The service was amazing, I regret not asking my waiters name because he absolutely made the experience so good! The service was good and the food was GREAT! Affordable fine dining in my opinion. To top it off, he got a piece of tiramisu cake for free for his birthday! We have already recommended this place to friends and only left there 2 hours ago😂 We will most definitely be back again! Thank you!
Victoria Bourdon
Our server was great. Steak came under cooked they took it back, then proceeded to burn it and dry it out. Didn't comp or anything for the burnt unedible steak. I'm not sure if it will be worth returning.