Salvatore's Tomato Pies Sun Prairie WI

Jeremy Gesicki

Visited Salvatore's for dinner with my daughter. Very cool restaurant and atmosphere. Service was great - attentive and polite. We had the truffle fries and a large Fat Uncle Tony pizza. The fries were amazing...my daughter said they are her new favorite and would stop again for the fries alone. The pizza was equally fantastic. We ended up bringing half the pizza back home with us. However, the coolest thing might have been the robot that delivered pizzas and salads from the back of the restaurant to the front for carryout. It was so cool. It also looks like their carryout business was quite busy...which I would consider carryout in the future, but the atmosphere inside is certainly worth going inside to sit down. Great place. Will visit again and again!

Peter Dettmer

By far the best place for authentic pizza pie! Various combinations of fantastic, local ingredients are used for some amazing pizzas, and the burgers are very tasty, too! Friendly staff make it an excellent experience for small or large families. Cocktails are great. Good beer selection. Must try the wings as an appetizer!

Bentley Wolfe

I have been to Sal's sun prairie location at least twenty times since I first rated it five stars (and I do not live close!) They have NEVER let us down. Every salad, every pizza has been just outstanding. Over what, five or six years? Even takeout during the pandemic was excellent. It is the best in the area, no doubt.