Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Reviews Menomonee Falls WI
Reviews of Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Menomonee Falls WI
Richard Janowski
I like the food at Olive Garden especially when prepared properly. On Sunday May 15th, I had the occasion to be invited by some friends to visit this Menomonee Falls location. I’d only heard mixed things about it since it opened and now I’d finally get to check it out.
We deliberately picked a late afternoon time hoping it would be less busy and the staff more attentive. And it turned out to be a good choice on both fronts.
The waitress was very friendly and attentive. The entrees we chose were Lasagna, the Tour of Italy and the Seafood Alfredo which is one of my favorites.
We opted for the salad to go with the dinner and we were not disappointed. It arrived quickly and loaded with toppings and had the right amount of their signature dressing. The bread sticks were pleasantly warm and we were off to a great start.
The food arrived a bit too quickly as we hadn’t finished the salad but better than being late and/or cold.
I was pleased with the Alfredo and my companions had similar opinions about their food.
Refills on the drinks were regular and we never had to ask for anything as the waitress was mostly always available.
There was nothing to complain about and though I’d never been there before I was able to find the location without any problems.
After having been to their previous location on Brown Deer Road in Milwaukee many times and was just as regularly disappointed, I would consider going back here on a Friday or Saturday night to see if the experience would be any different.
Lindsey Doman
I honestly went into this place expecting ok service/food based on past experiences at other Olive Gardens, but was pleasantly surprised and proven wrong. The service and food was excellent. The sweet lady that served us was very attentive even with all the other tables. It was some of the best service I've ever had anywhere.
Kristina Thomas
Came for my son’s birthday a few weeks ago. They made it very special for him. Our waiter Dwayne was very nice and friendly, he was funny and checked on us often. We got what we asked for and food was fast and fresh. Even brought my son dessert and sang happy birthday to him. This was by far our best visit to any Olive Garden, will be coming again.
Karen Didier
The best Olive Garden we have ever been to. It's updated, it looks sleek inside. We had great service. If you are there Fridays and Sundays ask for Dwayne. We had a fantastic time. Thank you Dwayne!!!! 💕
Ninji522
Well, it's olive garden, not too much mystery here. Our server was friendly and the food was the exact same as its always been which is decent Italian with the yummy breadsticks and salad. This is a newer location so it was clean and updated. The prices however are kind of a mixed bag. The chicken Alfredo has jumped to 18 bucks as is the case with most main dishes. The kids menu conversely was very well proportioned and only 6 bucks so they kind of even out (not really). Realistically though at these inflated prices I would much rather find an authentic Italian restaurant with some ambiance. The draw of olive garden was always decent Italian food at decent prices and while the food is still good, the prices not so much.
Richard Janowski
I like the food at Olive Garden especially when prepared properly. On Sunday May 15th, I had the occasion to be invited by some friends to visit this Menomonee Falls location. I’d only heard mixed things about it since it opened and now I’d finally get to check it out. We deliberately picked a late afternoon time hoping it would be less busy and the staff more attentive. And it turned out to be a good choice on both fronts. The waitress was very friendly and attentive. The entrees we chose were Lasagna, the Tour of Italy and the Seafood Alfredo which is one of my favorites. We opted for the salad to go with the dinner and we were not disappointed. It arrived quickly and loaded with toppings and had the right amount of their signature dressing. The bread sticks were pleasantly warm and we were off to a great start. The food arrived a bit too quickly as we hadn’t finished the salad but better than being late and/or cold. I was pleased with the Alfredo and my companions had similar opinions about their food. Refills on the drinks were regular and we never had to ask for anything as the waitress was mostly always available. There was nothing to complain about and though I’d never been there before I was able to find the location without any problems. After having been to their previous location on Brown Deer Road in Milwaukee many times and was just as regularly disappointed, I would consider going back here on a Friday or Saturday night to see if the experience would be any different.
Lindsey Doman
I honestly went into this place expecting ok service/food based on past experiences at other Olive Gardens, but was pleasantly surprised and proven wrong. The service and food was excellent. The sweet lady that served us was very attentive even with all the other tables. It was some of the best service I've ever had anywhere.
Kristina Thomas
Came for my son’s birthday a few weeks ago. They made it very special for him. Our waiter Dwayne was very nice and friendly, he was funny and checked on us often. We got what we asked for and food was fast and fresh. Even brought my son dessert and sang happy birthday to him. This was by far our best visit to any Olive Garden, will be coming again.
Karen Didier
The best Olive Garden we have ever been to. It's updated, it looks sleek inside. We had great service. If you are there Fridays and Sundays ask for Dwayne. We had a fantastic time. Thank you Dwayne!!!! 💕
Ninji522
Well, it's olive garden, not too much mystery here. Our server was friendly and the food was the exact same as its always been which is decent Italian with the yummy breadsticks and salad. This is a newer location so it was clean and updated. The prices however are kind of a mixed bag. The chicken Alfredo has jumped to 18 bucks as is the case with most main dishes. The kids menu conversely was very well proportioned and only 6 bucks so they kind of even out (not really). Realistically though at these inflated prices I would much rather find an authentic Italian restaurant with some ambiance. The draw of olive garden was always decent Italian food at decent prices and while the food is still good, the prices not so much.