Otto's Restaurant & Bar Reviews Madison WI
Reviews of Otto's Restaurant & Bar Madison WI
Adam Schroeder
Favorite restaurant in the entire city, hands down. We loved coming here for their weekly wine pairings as they would create a new menu each week. It made for a fantastic date night. We didn’t live nearby at all but it was always well worth the trip. We now live out of state but really look forward to being back.
Mariana Aleman
My husband and I ate here for our 13th anniversary. It was our first time visiting this restaurant. It was kind of weird being in the first floor with no one really saying anything or greeting the guests right away. There is really no sign that you should go upstairs for your reservation. After a couple awkward stares we were told to go upstairs. Our waitress was very kind and attentive; she always made sure we had drinks and bread. I think her name is "Quin/Queen'' (sorry if this is not correct spelling). We would love to return as long as she's our waitress again. I had lamb chops and my husband had seafood dish. We both enjoyed our dinners. I had an Otto's Manhattan cocktail, which I honestly didn't really like but I finished it. The wine we had was great! Our dessert was yummy! Overall I would recommend this place for a nice meal.
Robbi Webb
My husband and I were married in front of the fireplace at Otto's with a guest list of about 25. This was back in 2007. The ambiance was amazing - just perfect for our quaint little second wedding with family and a few close friends. The food was amazing, the staff was attentive and the setting romantic. Everytime we have returned since our wedding 15 years ago, we receive a free dessert and when possible, we get seated right in front of the fireplace! The menu is pricey but worth it and the atmosphere makes for a very memorable and romantic evening of fine dining.
nancy barnes
Ok experience. Way too pricey. Beautiful setting and pleasant decor. Pleasant wait staff.
Michael Honey-Arcement
Very attentive staff. Reservation only. We enjoyed our 10 year anniversary here and were very happy with that decision.
Adam Schroeder
Favorite restaurant in the entire city, hands down. We loved coming here for their weekly wine pairings as they would create a new menu each week. It made for a fantastic date night. We didn’t live nearby at all but it was always well worth the trip. We now live out of state but really look forward to being back.
Mariana Aleman
My husband and I ate here for our 13th anniversary. It was our first time visiting this restaurant. It was kind of weird being in the first floor with no one really saying anything or greeting the guests right away. There is really no sign that you should go upstairs for your reservation. After a couple awkward stares we were told to go upstairs. Our waitress was very kind and attentive; she always made sure we had drinks and bread. I think her name is "Quin/Queen'' (sorry if this is not correct spelling). We would love to return as long as she's our waitress again. I had lamb chops and my husband had seafood dish. We both enjoyed our dinners. I had an Otto's Manhattan cocktail, which I honestly didn't really like but I finished it. The wine we had was great! Our dessert was yummy! Overall I would recommend this place for a nice meal.
Robbi Webb
My husband and I were married in front of the fireplace at Otto's with a guest list of about 25. This was back in 2007. The ambiance was amazing - just perfect for our quaint little second wedding with family and a few close friends. The food was amazing, the staff was attentive and the setting romantic. Everytime we have returned since our wedding 15 years ago, we receive a free dessert and when possible, we get seated right in front of the fireplace! The menu is pricey but worth it and the atmosphere makes for a very memorable and romantic evening of fine dining.
nancy barnes
Ok experience. Way too pricey. Beautiful setting and pleasant decor. Pleasant wait staff.
Michael Honey-Arcement
Very attentive staff. Reservation only. We enjoyed our 10 year anniversary here and were very happy with that decision.