Tally's Tap & Eatery Waukesha WI

Andrew B.

We met up with some friends based on their recommendation. What a cool place, the menu was very well balanced and being a bit of a foodie my expectations are higher. My dinner was AWESOME and the drinks were well crafted. Overall it was a fun time and would recommend you pay them a visit. Also, the staff is Top Notch!!

Kelly Swets

Been to Tally's more times than I can count and never leave unsatisfied. Tonight was a busy, rainy Saturday there. We went with our 3 kids (all under 5 yrs old) and were treated very kindly by staff and other diners. The fajita wrap is so darn delicious (my fav thing on the menu), and their tally fries are unique and tasty. And their stuffed pretzels and pizza- both so good! It's louder than average and although we love sitting at the bar, the restaurant atmosphere isn't the greatest. But we go back time and time again. Thanks, Tally's Team for providing this community with a great place to dine!

S. M. (Smacks)

Went with group of six. Food was good, server was excellent, but they missed one burger on the order and it didn’t come out until almost everyone else had finished their meal. They did give us a drink chip for the inconvenience. Still a great place to go with lots of different food options, appetizers, pizzas and sandwiches. Just a note that they do charge a credit card fee on all meals when using credit card, so you may want to bring cash.