The Bay Restaurant Whitefish Bay WI

Linda Sutton

I give only 3 stars for the place. The food was very good. Unfortunately when our party of 3 order a drink that we thought sounded so refreshing on a hot day turned out to be awful!! None of us could even drink it. I stated to the waitress/bartender that we needed a glass of 7up because our drinks were way to limey!! There was so much lime juice in our Rasberi Gimlets that none of us could drink them. The person serving us could have said "Oh I'm so sorry about the drinks would you like to try something else " but she just said oh and gave us the 7up!! For 9 dollars a drink this wasn't very good bartender service. Will not return!!

Tim Phelps

Really disappointed in the experience we had here. My wife's baked potato had dirt and tiny pieces of gravel on it, which she unfortunately didn't realize until after she found some in her mouth. We asked the waitress to let the kitchen know so no one else would run into this, hopefully--it had clearly not been cleaned well. Secondly, when we were nearing the end of our meal, our waitress sat down in the dining room to have her own meal. Not really a problem, I guess, if she's still checking in on us or if she has handed our table off to someone else. But that was not what happened. We sat and waited for almost ten minutes after finishing our food, waiting for her to notice that we were ready for our check, all while she was sitting in plain sight of us. I eventually had to get up from my table and walk to her to ask for a check. Completely unprofessional, and just bad service. Finally, our check still included the gravelly potato, which should have been basic awareness to remove without asking. Like I said, really disappointing, and we will not be back.

Matthew Mead

Fantastic staff. Fantastic food. The owner is pretty neat too 🔥